DEATH'S GIFT -- November 2007
DEATH’S GIFT -- November 2007
Help us, Lord, to receive and understand your gospel, so that we may find light in this darkness, faith in our doubts, and comfort for one another in your saving words. Amen.
[From: THE PROMISE OF HIS GLORY: SERVICES AND PRAYERS FOR THE SEASON FROM ALL SAINTS TO CANDLEMAS: Church Publishing House and Mowbray, 1991]
Please be seated.
Let me welcome you to the 2007 Praying Our Goodbyes service.
Once again we gather here around All Soul’s Day and an approaching holiday season that is too often filled for many of us with difficult memories to pray and meditate about the losses in our lives.
For some, these will be raw, recent losses; for others, more distant ones; but for all there is still that gnawing feeling that something, no matter how far removed it is, is still missing.
“Grief”, says the writer Joan Didion in her memoir of her husband’s death, “The Year of Magical Thinking”, “turns out to be a place none of us know until we get there;” adding that, “nor can we know ahead of the fact… the unending absence that follows, the void, the very opposite of meaning, the relentless succession of moments during which we will confront the experience of meaningless itself.”
As we pray our goodbyes again tonight, we look to the life-giving mystery of the Eucharist to help us regain that lost meaning.
Once again our service is shared with the Saint Michael’s Friends of Music First Sunday at Five November program, and we thank Tim Getz and his wonderful musicians for their continuing participation and support.
As always, Tim’s selection of music for the service is most appropriate: Purcell’s “Funeral Music for Queen Mary” and William Byrd’s “O quam gloriosum.”
Our offering from this service will again go through the Anglican Communion’s Compass Rose Society to the Aids Project at St. Dunstan’s Cathedral in Johannesburg. There, they use these funds to purchase coffins for AIDS victims whose families cannot afford them.
The badge I’m wearing symbolizes our parish’s support of this ministry at St. Dustan’s, and you’re most welcome to take one for yourself from the basket in the back on your way out. A parishioner has donated them.
And I’d like to remind you that our parish is very fortunate to have a beautiful memorial garden—the Garden of the Good Shepherd—which is located behind the wall on your left as you walk out to the parking lot from the church. To date, there are 72 memorials there. If you’d like to visit the garden tonight, the candles will indicate the way, and if you’d like more information about it, please contact our rector, The Rev’d Peter Haynes.
***
My text for this evening is taken from the third chapter of the Book of Wisdom:
"But the souls of the righteous are in the hand of God,
and no torment will ever touch them.
2In the eyes of the foolish they seemed to have died,
and their departure was thought to be a disaster,
3and their going from us to be their destruction;
but they are at peace.
“Those who trust in him will understand truth,
and the faithful will abide with him in love,
because grace and mercy are upon his holy ones,
and he watches over his elect.” (Wisdom 3, 1-3, 9)*
We even named our dog – she was fittingly, perhaps, a spirited, golden haired sheltie – “Lady Diana”.
For short, we’d call her just “Diana” or, when we were being silly, “Di-Di”.
That’s how much the outwardly glamorous life of the Princess of Wales had suffused our household during her brief fling with royalty: from the gala wedding in St. Paul’s Cathedral that we watched on a rented television at a friend’s condo in Sun Valley, to the sad sight of Prince William and Prince Harry, heads bowed, walking behind her coffin on its way to the altar in Westminster Abbey following her death in the Alma auto-tunnel near the Seine.
That was August of 1997 – 10 years ago.
Little did I know then, as we watched the funeral and wept together, that Susan, my own dear princess, would herself be dead in 9 months.
I’m not sure quite how I will mark this upcoming milestone anniversary even though it seems that memorial celebrations are quite common these days and take many different forms.
Certainly there won’t be best selling books and TV specials about Sue as there have been about Diana. While my wife was quite remarkable in many notable ways, only a relative few will know this.
Nor will I issue a commemorative coin as the British Virgin Islands and the Falklands have done for Diana’s tenth, nor even organize a conference as St. Vincent College in Pennsylvania did in recognition of Mother Teresa’s tenth this past September.
Certainly I won’t put on rally as some did ten years on to remember Jill Philips, an animal rights activist who some think was murdered at an anti-veal protest in Great Britain.
Sue loved her horses, but I’m certain that she’d find that a bit over the top.
It goes on and on: Last July 15 a special ballet was presented in Milan to honor the late fashion designer Gianni Versace on the 10th anniversary of his death. NPR prominently noted the murder of rapper Tupak Shakur 10 years after his death and there were widely broadcast ceremonies in Israel to mark the 10 years since the assassination if Yitzhak Rabin. And then there was that vigil in Memphis last August – Elvis died 30 years ago.
Writing this past September, Ruth Gledhill, the religion correspondent for London’s newspaper the Times noted:
“Memorial services have become one of the churches’ biggest growth areas. For public figures the services get bigger and more frequent, with death anniversaries being marked as well as the original death. But memorial services are increasingly following and sometimes even supplanting funerals for private individuals as well.”
Gledhill quoted one Church of England expert who speculated on the reason for this trend: “'They have taken the place of funerals in many cases. When memorial services first started, they were for the great and the good. Now everybody has one, and why not?”
He said that the past few years had seen a 'desertion' of the funeral format. 'People do not like funerals,’ he noted, ‘I think because of momento mori. People do not like to be that near death. A memorial service does concentrate tremendously on a person’s life. That has become more acceptable than dwelling on the fact of death.'
Sister Joyce Rupp, the author of “Praying our Goodbyes”, the book from which we take the name of tonight’s service asks in this regard:
“Do we ever get used to saying goodbye? Or should we? Saying goodbye helps us experience the depth of our human condition. It leads us to a much deeper understanding of what it means to live in its mystery and its wholeness.”
This perhaps, is one of the best reasons that we should, every so often, recall and memorialize our losses and I think that this service offers us a way to do that here in our own parish.
But while recalling publicly the life and the contributions of someone we deem exceptional may have value in providing closure or a belated, less emotional recognition, I personally still prefer more private tributes.
Our Jewish friends, for example, have a brief, sober service called Yizkor – literally “May God Remember”—a ten minute prayer for the dead in which the loved ones to be remembered are named. It’s a personal time to reflect on one’s relationship to a loved one. Some congregations even have a separate Yizkor service which must be a bit like this one, but in their own worship tradition.
I suspect that my memorial to Susan on June 3, 2008 will involve simply a visit to her grave along with a few family members and close friends, her favorite yellow rose and some readings that I’ve put together from the “The Book of Common Prayer” and the Bible.
I think I’ll start by reading the passage from the fourth chapter of the Song of Solomon that begins; “How beautiful you are my love, how very beautiful…” Song of Solomon 4:1*
***
For the past six years we have been holding these “Praying Our Goodbyes” services now on the occasion of All Soul’s Day and in anticipation of the upcoming holiday season when, as Elvis himself reminded us, there can be a “Blue Christmas without You”.
Many of us have found Sister Rupp’s book especially valuable. In it, she describes how we can approach our losses and all our leave-takings spiritually, not just saying our goodbyes but praying them, thus growing in our relationship with a loving, comforting God who does not want us to suffer.
This is a God who will be with us through all of our goodbyes and who will lead us to what she calls “new hellos" in a persistent cycle that we encounter throughout our lives – the many “goodbye – hello” pairings that punctuate our experience – everything from the death of a loved one and its subsequent resolution to the loss of a job and the finding of a new one or to sending the kids off to college and reclaiming some personal time for ourselves.
Here are several of Sister Rupp’s observations which I find worthy of our rehearsal:
"The word goodbye – originally 'God be with ye' or 'Go with God' – was a recognition that God was a significant part of the going. When you dreaded or feared the journey, there was strength in remembering that the One who gave and cherished life would be there to protect and console. Goodbye was a blessing of love, proclaiming the belief that if God went with you, you would never be alone…To the traveler it meant: 'We cannot keep you from this journey. We hurt deeply…you have made your home in our heart. Yet we know your leaving is essential to your growth. So go, go with God…'"
But she also warns us that,
“Grief has a way of plundering our prayer life leaving us feeling empty and immobile. At the time we need most to experience the compassion of God, we very often feel a distance in that relationship; the feeling of presence is gone and it may take time for it to come back.”
At these difficult times, we need to remember that God understands us and accepts us in our sadness which, along with loss, is a part of the human condition.
She also notes that,
“We ought not be afraid of the partings that life asks of us. Nor ought we hold back in giving ourselves to love, to the wonderful growth opportunities of investing ourselves in people and events."
This is much harder, but it is the heart of her message.
It means letting go and moving on, and she encourages us to use our suffering creatively to "…peer inside our own tombs of unfinishedness or incompleteness [to] discover… resiliency, vitality, fidelity, love and endurance."
Joan Didion commented on this, too. She said this:
“I also know that if we are to live ourselves, there comes a point we must relinquish the dead, let them go, keep them dead.
“Let them become the photograph on the table.
“Let them become the name on the trust accounts…”
But, she concluded,
“Knowing this does not make it any easier to let go of him…” And she’s certainly right about that.
We are, I think during this vulnerable time of bereavement, always in danger of what the narrator in Andrew Holleran’s newest novel “Grief” tells us: “…some people cling to grief because it’s all they have left of the person who’s gone. ‘As long as you have that, you’re not alone — you have them…’
Where can we look for help? The roots of our faith, not surprisingly, can offer some relief.
In his well-regarded study of death and bereavement, “Death’s Gift”, originally published in 1978 and recently re-released in a new edition in the UK, Nicholas Peter Harvey, a Roman Catholic lay theologian, offers some new insights on bereavement, drawing parallels between what happened to the disciples after the death of Jesus and to bereavement as a growth opportunity.
In what was a truly startling thought to me, Harvey reminds us that the very foundation of the Church is the testimony of a group of bereaved disciples: the authoritative witness to Christ as the manifestation of God comes from a group of people who, like all of us were, are alone hapless, confused and fearful following the death of a loved one. Their bereavement showed them the way forward into the meaning and power of Jesus as Savior.
According to Harvey, death and bereavement in our own lives when touched by the resurrection can yield a new, richer relationship to the person who has died and, as Sister Rupp also notes, provide the opportunity for personal growth in those who survive.
The idea that Jesus’ death set humankind free, as reflected by what happened to the disciples after the crucifixion, finds resonance in our own bereavements.
In Jesus’ resurrection appearances, Thomas touched the risen Lord, Mary Magdalene clung to him and some of the disciples ate and drank with him. All these events helped the disciples see that the person they had loved was now alive in a timeless reality.
The following somewhat mystical quote from Harvey’s friend Anglican Bishop Stephen Verney after the bishop’s wife died captures what he means:
“Things which belong in time and things which belong outside of time, are trying to express themselves through the same events. They happen in clock time, but they are also timeless.”
Bishop Verney finds echoes of the resurrection appearances in the relationship between the bereaved and the deceased, and says that by exploring the resurrection as metaphor, wider perspectives can open for the bereaved as they did for the disciples.
“When someone you love has died the barrier between “in time” and “outside of time” grows very thin and a new pattern of events is set free to happen around us,” Verney wrote. These appearances “have to give way to something more important still, which is the experience that we too can come alive and be with the deceased now in that same reality beyond time.”
Maybe you too have found the special “thin places”, between “in time” and “outside of time”, the spots where Celtic spirituality tells us that this world and the realm of the spirit come close together. Maybe you too have “crossed over” once or twice and found some companionship and comfort.
In sum, Harvey contends that the death of a loved one is at its root a growing point, with all the pain and struggle which that suggests.
It is a genuinely critical, creative moment in a person’s development, not simply just something to be got over -- a stoical return to normalcy.
He stresses that it is an opportunity for growth, not a guaranteed process, which is best assured by having the bereaved, as Didion alluded to, letting the deceased die, freeing them from the danger of imprisonment in a moment in the past.
And echoing Andrew Holleran’s narrator in “Grief”, Harvey offers what for me is a profound insight for us to consider about all this: the successful bereavement process involves letting go of that which is in ourselves which seeks to continue to cling to the beloved as a focus of false security.
Harvey calls the distresses involved in being freed from this type of security seeking “growing pains”. Ten years on, I still have a few growing pains, as I suspect you do to, wherever you are in your journey through grief.
May our resurrected Lord lead you through these and help you find many new glorious hellos. For “Grace and mercy are on his holy ones, and he watches over his elect.”
Let us pray:
O god, who brought us to birth,
And in whose arms we die,
In our grief and shock,
Contain and comfort us,
Embrace us with your love,
Give us hope in our confusion
And grace to let go into new life,
Through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Amen
(Janet Morley, 1951- )
*How beautiful you are, my love,
how very beautiful!
Your eyes are doves
behind your veil.
Your hair is like a flock of goats,
moving down the slopes of Gilead.
Your teeth are like a flock of shorn ewes
that have come up from the washing,
all of which bear twins,
and not one among them is bereaved.
Your lips are like a crimson thread,
and your mouth is lovely.
Your cheeks are like halves of a pomegranate
behind your veil.
Your neck is like the tower of David,
built in courses;
on it hang a thousand bucklers,
all of them shields of warriors.
Your two breasts are like two fawns,
twins of a gazelle,
that feed among the lilies.
Until the day breathes
and the shadows flee,
I will hasten to the mountain of myrrh
and the hill of frankincense.
You are altogether beautiful, my love;
there is no flaw in you.
Come with me from Lebanon, my bride;
come with me from Lebanon.
Depart* from the peak of Amana,
from the peak of Senir and Hermon,
from the dens of lions,
from the mountains of leopards.